I was at this website:  www.okinawaprogram.com and decided to pop my information into its BMI calulator. This is what it told me:

Your Body Mass Index (BMI) is above the normal range of weight for your height. You may be at a higher risk for heart disease, Type 2 diabetes and other potentially serious health problems. The Okinawa diet plan will help you safely lose the weight you need to get your BMI into a "normal", healthier, range

It also stated this: Your Healthy Weight Range: 125.3-162.5 lbs.

Here's what you need to know:
1. My height - 5' 9"  -  My Weight 170 - My Age 56 - My BMI 25.1
2. All BMI calculators will come up with the same result (25.1) and state that I am  slightly overweight
3. Its "healthy weight" suggestion is downright dangerous. If I weighed 125.3 (loss of 45-pounds), I would either a) be dead b) be anorexic c) be in the hospital d) look and feel like crap
4. If I weighed the top-end of its healthy range - 162.5, while I would be healthy, people would comment that I was too skinny. And, I would agree.
5. Its suggestion that I am "at higher risk" for heart disease, Type 2 diabetes, or other serious health problems is preposterous.  I won't bore you with my lipid results, blood pressure, and other health outcomes, however, I am in perfect health.

So, please beware of the BMI calculator. Use it as a guide and certainly not as gospel.
 


Comments

Alexandra
12/07/2012 6:21pm

Thank you for this. I have a medical issues where my weight fluctuates severely, and I am at a current high point. And sometimes when I see myself in the mirror, I feel like crap when I hear echoes of our "pro-skinny" society in my head telling that I am fat or ugly. I'm 5'7, 160lbs, and 27 years old. I was just told my BMI is 25.1 as well. But you're post shows me that BMI is not something that I should take seriously. I don't look overweight, and only have a small bit of a belly. Thank you for your post!

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply